Pennsylvania Care Facility Ratings

Garden Spot Village

433 S Kinzer Avenue, New Holland, PA 17557 · 717-355-6247 · Map and directions

Nursing home · 73 certified beds · Nonprofit (Non profit - Corporation) · Lancaster County · CMS number 396079

Fewer concerns Confidence: High

2 citations for harming residents and 0 immediate-jeopardy citations in about three years of inspections.

29Risk score (0 = least concern, 100 = most)
#524of 656 PA homes, #1 = most concern
5★Medicare overall star rating
5.52Nurse hours per resident per day (PA median 3.64)
29%Nursing staff who left in a year (PA median 45%)
$8,018Federal fines, about 3 years

Location and nearby homes

Nearby nursing homesRatingMilesMedicare stars
Fairmount HomesEphrata Fewest concerns 4.55★
Ephrata ManorEphrata Fewer concerns 6.74★
Maple FarmAkron Fewest concerns 7.95★
Zerbe Sisters Nursing Center,Narvon Fewer concerns 8.25★
Gardens at Stevens, theStevens Most serious concerns 9.32★
Landis HomesLititz Fewest concerns 10.25★

Straight-line distance. Location is the address CMS geocoded, so Street View may show a neighboring building.

Nearest emergency rooms

HospitalMedicare hospital ratingMiles
Wellspan Ephrata Community Hospital Ephrata · Acute Care Hospitals 5 of 5 stars 8.2 Directions
Upmc Lititz Lititz · Acute Care Hospitals 4 of 5 stars 12.5 Directions
Lancaster General Hospital Lancaster · Acute Care Hospitals 5 of 5 stars 12.7 Directions

Hospitals with an emergency department, from CMS Hospital General Information. Star ratings are Medicare's overall hospital rating (1 to 5); some hospitals have too little data to be rated. Straight-line miles. In an emergency, call 911: ambulances choose the hospital.

Inspection findings

Every health citation in CMS's current window (about three years), newest first. Letters A–L are CMS's severity scale; G and above mean residents were harmed or put in immediate danger. Full report text is on Medicare Care Compare and ProPublica.

Nov 13, 2025 · 1 citation · includes complaint investigation

  • Level G: Actual harm (isolated) · Quality of care · repeat
    F0684 · Provide appropriate treatment and care according to orders, resident’s preferences and goals.

Dec 13, 2024 · 1 citation

  • Level D: Potential for harm (isolated) · Nursing and doctor services
    F0947 · Ensure nurse aides have the skills they need to care for residents, and give nurse aides education in dementia care and abuse prevention.

Jan 5, 2024 · 2 citations

  • Level G: Actual harm (isolated) · Quality of care
    F0684 · Provide appropriate treatment and care according to orders, resident’s preferences and goals.
  • Level D: Potential for harm (isolated) · Care planning
    F0641 · Ensure each resident receives an accurate assessment.

Fines and payment bans

DateTypeAmount
Jan 5, 2024Fine$8,018

Who owns and runs it

5% or greater direct ownership interest (1)
  • Garden Spot Communities · Organization · 100% · since 07/01/2016
Corporate director (9)
  • Aldrich, Donald · Individual · since 07/01/2023
  • Bender, Tim · Individual · since 07/01/2023
  • Edwards, Carl · Individual · since 07/01/2023
  • Hess, Philip · Individual · since 01/01/2024
  • Hoover, Joyce · Individual · since 07/01/2023
  • Musser, Karen · Individual · since 07/01/2023
  • Rittersbach, Elma · Individual · since 07/01/2023
  • Stoltzfus, Alphaus · Individual · since 07/01/2023
  • Vega, David · Individual · since 07/01/2023
Corporate officer (2)
  • Lindsey, Stephen · Individual · since 07/01/2023
  • Weber, Nathaniel · Individual · since 06/11/2022
Operational/managerial control (3)
  • Garden Spot Communities · Organization · since 07/01/2016
  • Lindsey, Stephen · Individual · since 07/01/2023
  • Weber, Nathaniel · Individual · since 06/11/2022
W-2 managing employee (1)
  • Rouvre Haeusler, Christina · Individual · since 07/30/2020

Most recent standard inspection: Jan 9, 2026. Data from CMS, release of Oct 1, 2026. The rating is this site's method and opinion, not a government finding. Citations under dispute can change. Spotted an error? See corrections.